I have not said much about the current upheavals surrounding illegal immigration because there are so many opinions flying around. To be honest, I’ve had to let the different ideas percolate in my head a bit to really understand what I’d be willing to support. Just as I was coming to some firm conclusions, the President decided that he needed to address the nation last night about his position on the matter.
After the address, Stef asked me what I thought. My answer was, “It’s better than I feared, but not as good as I hoped.” I do think that the President is about as far away from his base on this issue as he is with anything else. I have a very difficult time with any solution that downplays the current law for some kind of compromise. I’m all for plea bargains in the courtroom, but I’m not so excited about pleading out several million people who don’t seem to have much love for this country anyway.
To me the bottom line is that there’s no point in discussing the illegals already here or how to discourage more from coming until we actually have a firm handle on the border. I feel like we have about ten guys with sandbags trying to stem a tidal wave while we make allowances for how much water we’ll learn to live with in our house. That’s not enforcement, that’s capitulation. Stem the tide to a trickle, and then we can talk about the next step.
I guess my fear of any so-called “comprehensive” solution is that we’ve tried that in the past. The result usually is that the items that are easy (welcoming the illegals, overlooking existing laws, etc.) happen quickly and forever. Items that are hard (enforcing the border, deporting illegals, denying services, etc.) happen slowly and after many lawsuits and usually fade away. I’d rather see an attempt to do just the hard things and prove that it can be done.
I applaud the President for discussing some details about the hard part, but I’ll believe it when I see it. There just hasn’t been enough intestinal fortitude in Washington to pull it off in the past. I do worry about too much reliance on technology. He discussed a tamperproof ID card. In my industry I’ve discovered there there really is no such thing as the unbreakable code, the unhackable computer, or tamperproof technology. If there’s enough money in doing it, someone will figure it out. Besides, there will be some requirement for employers to have access to machines that can verify the card. I’d prefer a way for employers to give names and SS# to a secure website and have it validate that they match, that the person is alive, and that the person is the right age. Combine that with some severe penalties for employing illegals and the employers become part of the border enforcement team. Make the jobs for illegals dry up, and they’ll deport themselves. No need for trains or buses.
I’m a believer in free markets. If you want to change behavior, you should change the markets not simply make laws and build barriers. We know enough when we raise our children. When a baby wants to play with something he shouldn’t, don’t just put it on a higher shelf (he’ll start climbing for it). Remove it from view. Remove it as a possible choice. We need to come up with a way to make coming to the US illegally unpalatable. If it was next to impossible to get a job as an illegal, they’d line up to get citizenship. I’m happy to allow them in that way.
So, I guess I have to say that I differ with the President’s conclusions about what to do with the folks already here and how to discourage more from coming. I think we need to be more serious about this and recognize the threat to our national security and our culture. I love George W. Bush, but I just think he’s wrong here.
Here’s hoping it won’t create an unrepairable situation because it’s not going to get appreciably better anytime soon.